The Safest And Unsafest Budget Cars In South Africa

The Automobile Association (AA) has published its 2019 Entry-Level Vehicle Safety Report, which assesses the safety features on some of the most popular entry-level vehicles (priced under R180 000) available in South Africa. 

The report looked at 27 vehicles, and aims to highlight the importance of safety features in new and popular cars, how these can save lives, and encourage buyers to consider safety above pricing.  

“Price is, unfortunately, a driving factor in people’s decisions to buy vehicles. What we would like to see more of is people considering other elements of the vehicles they intend buying such as safety features, which can mean the difference between life and death,” the AA said.

Some of the safety features the report looked for in these vehicles were, among others, active safety features such as anti-lock braking or electronic stability control, and passive safety features such as airbags.

These vehicles were then categorised into three groups, based on the safety ratings achieved. Seven vehicles achieved ‘acceptable safety’ ratings (an improvement from last year’s report, which only had two), sixteen achieved ‘moderate safety’ and four were classed as ‘poor safety’ – or – ‘most likely to kill you.’

Let’s take a look at the findings.

While You’re Here: Cars With The Best And Worst Resale Value In South Africa

The Safest And Unsafest Entry-Level Vehicles

First off, let’s take a look at the seven vehicles that scored 50 or higher, making them the safest entry-level vehicles currently available. Three of these belonged to Toyota, and one each to Volkswagen, Renault, Smart, Suzuki and Honda.

Of these, the VW Take Up! achieved the highest score, with 6.38 out of a possible 7.5. This was followed by the Renault, and then the Toyota Aygo.  

Acceptable Safety: 

• Volkswagen Take Up!

• Renault Sandero 66kw turbo expression

• Toyota Aygo 1.0

• Smart ForTwo

• Toyota Etios Hatch 1.5 Xi HB

• Honda Amaze 1.2 Trend

• Suzuki Ignis 1.2 GL

Vehicles placed into the ‘moderate safety’ category achieved scores between 20 and 50, with the Suzuki Celerio achieving the highest rating with 3.57 out of 7.5, and the lowest being the Haval 1 with a dismal score of 2.78. 

Moderate Safety:

• Suzuki Celerio 1.0 GA

• Datsun GOMid

• BAIC D20 hatch 1.3 Comfort

• Datsun GO+ Mid

• Datsun GO+ Panel Van

• Kia Picanto 1.0 Street

• Suzuki Swift hatch 1.2 GA

• Suzuki Swift DZire sedan 1.2 GA

• Mahindra KUV100 1.2 NXT K4+

• Honda Brio hatch 1.2 Trend

• Hyundai i10 Grand 1.0 Motion

• Renault Kwid 1.0 Expression 5 dr

• Kia Picanto MT 1.0 Style

• GWM M4

• Nissan Micra Active 1.2 Visia+

• Haval 1

And then, the following four vehicles achieved the lowest scores – all under 20 – with both the Nissan NP200 and the JMC achieving an absolute zero. We’ve spoken a little bit about the Nissan before, and other zero-rated vehicles, and the dangers that come with driving it.

Of these four, the Datsun achieved the best rating, with a score of 0.85 out of 7.5.

Vehicles Most Likely To Kill You (Poor Safety): 

• Datsun GO+ 1.2 Lux

• Nissan NP200

• JMC 4×2 Boarding

• Kia Picanto 1.0 Start

While You’re Here: Beware Of These Zero-Star Vehicles

In Conclusion – The State Of Entry-Level Vehicles In South Africa

One of the most noteworthy bits of information that we can take from this report is the fact that the vehicles ranked as safest and unsafest both retail at around the same price. The VW Take Up! retails at around R172 500, and the deathtrap-on-wheels JMC retails at around R176 880. 

Safety, then, really should be the most important thing that we take into account when purchasing a new vehicle. We have no excuse. 

According to the AA, the report results indicate a definite increase in safety features in vehicles, but it also highlights a crucial need for these features to be standardised across the board, instead of optional.  

Features such as anti-lock braking, electronic stability control and airbags save lives. These should not be seen as ‘nice-to-haves’ in the modern motoring world, but absolutely vital. 

With CompareGuru, You’ll Never Have To Deal With An Insurance Company Again! Contact The Guru To See How We Can Save You Money!

CompareGuru knows what’s good – you’ll never need another insurance comparison tool again!

Sign up to our newsletter to stay up-to-date on our latest tips on how to get the best out of your insurance, what insurance really means and how to avoid any pitfalls along the way.

CompareGuru has you covered.   


Insurance Guru

Insurance Guru is here to help you simplify the complicated world of insurance, so you can make smart insurance decisions and get the best insurance deals for your situation.

View all posts by Insurance Guru →